Paste your Google Webmaster Tools verification code here

Why Julian Assange shows that only intelligent machines can be truly rational

Posted by on February 11, 2016 in Economic Theory, Uncategorized | 2 comments

Why Julian Assange shows that only intelligent machines can be truly rational

Is Julian Assange rational? There are no prizes for guessing the responses of most City A.M. readers to this question. He faces questioning over allegations (which he denies) in Sweden, and he claims that America will try to extradite him and put him in prison for a very long time. Assange has chosen instead to live within the confines of the Ecuadorian embassy in London for over three years.

On one level, economic theory can easily account for his behaviour. As a rational decision-maker, he estimated the potential costs and benefits of alternative courses of action, compared them to his preferences, and made what for him was the best possible decision. He probably considers the embassy to be preferable to life in a maximum security US jail. All standard economics textbook stuff: the costs of leaving the embassy outweigh the benefits.

But in forming his views on the costs and benefits, Assange had to make some quite difficult assessments of the likelihood of future events. What are the chances of him being charged by the Swedes? What is the probability of the Americans both trying and succeeding in getting him extradited? What is the likelihood of being found guilty if he is ever bundled over to the US? The answers are not obvious and there is no easy solution.

Even his ploy of getting the ludicrous United Nations panel to pronounce that he has been “arbitrarily detained” shows the inherent uncertainty around future events. Assange could have been almost certain that it would find in his favour. But it would have been hard for him to anticipate the ridicule with which this has been received, even among the liberal left. Making choices which involve future consequences is a much more difficult problem than simple economic choice theory might lead us to believe.

Assange could perhaps have benefited from the remarkable algorithm developed by a team at Google Deep Mind, and described in a paper in the top scientific journal Nature last month. Their work seems to be a very important step towards creating intelligent machines. The programme defeated the European Go champion 5-0. “So what?” you might say. But Go is an immensely harder problem than chess to attack by purely straightforward computational power. Success depends much more on a deep intuition of what does or does not constitute a good position. The astonishing feature of the algorithm is that it makes moves, in positions which have occurred previously in human games, which even the strongest human players simply cannot understand.

The implications spread far beyond the game of Go. The algorithm faced a challenging decision-making task. The precise consequences of a move cannot be computed. The optimal solution is so complex that it is infeasible to approximate. Yet the algorithm succeeded. Maybe humans have created the first truly rational thinker.

Paul Ormerod

As Published in City AM on Wednesday 10th January 2016

Image: Julian Assange by Global Panorama licensed under CC BY 2.0

2 Comments

  1. Depoxito is the best online gambling site in Indonesia, following Depoxito you will
    setting the sensation of playing additional and liberal online gambling.
    We always innovate therefore that all our members
    can quality a sensation with playing at a real casino. Depoxito come up with the money for you the best flesh
    and blood casino feelings you can acquire past every the
    beautiful and sexy dealers, or grand vip saloon private room for our VIP zealot where you can perform one
    upon one subsequent to our special Dealer every just for yourself.

    Luxurious site and VIP class foster for you, a modern and easy-to-use site, friendly and always friendly Customer facilitate to back
    up you. Depoxito is the right another for those of you who want to ham it up online gambling without unbearable that your winnings will
    not be paid, Depoxito guarantees that every bet you place and win is authenticated and will be paid without
    incurring any unwritten deductions.
    Depoxito as a site that is a accomplice of international big bookmakers
    completely will not disappoint you as a faithful advocate of the Depoxito site and will continue
    to try additional updates and amend our security system hence that it can prevent
    our loyal members from the threat of personal data leakage, scam or fraud.

    Depoxito is with a trusted online gambling dealer
    that provides the most final gambling games in Indonesia, such as sportsbook, slot games, flesh and blood casino, lottery and online poker that you can appear in past just 1
    Account.
    In supplement to the supreme VIP encourage game on our site, we will pamper you our loyal members
    because you don’t infatuation a lot of IDs to work substitute gambling games.
    As a gambling site accredited by PAGCOR (Philippines
    Amusement and Gaming Corporation) Depoxito is afterward one of the number one
    gambling sites in Indonesia and has a fine reputation from all online
    gambling players in Indonesia.
    As we have said, we have a customer service that is always upon standby to benefits all your needs while playing upon our site, including for withdrawals and deposits that only bow to less than 3
    minutes, therefore we can be the best for enthusiast foster as a consequence
    our customer utility will standby 24 hour a morning
    and 7 days a week to relieve our believer and VIPs.

    And the most special from our site compared to extra sites is the added that we find the money for to
    our faithful members who continue to proceed upon our site
    will get the best promos and bonuses that we will come
    up with the money for you, we always follow the present and
    trends that are viral now in view of that the promos that we make are of course no less than any site.
    For VIP members we always provide special promos that are not written for that reason that our members continue to doing
    on our site depoxito.

  2. Depoxito is the best online gambling site in Indonesia, subsequent to Depoxito you will character the sensation of
    playing further and militant online gambling.
    We always innovate thus that every our members can mood a sensation like playing at a genuine casino.
    Depoxito offer you the best conscious casino feelings you can get next all
    the beautiful and sexy dealers, or grand vip saloon private room for
    our VIP enthusiast where you can fake one upon one in imitation of our special Dealer every just for yourself.

    Luxurious site and VIP class encouragement for you, a highly developed and easy-to-use site, kind and always friendly Customer
    serve to back you. Depoxito is the right unorthodox for
    those of you who desire to operate online gambling without heartbreaking
    that your winnings will not be paid, Depoxito guarantees that
    every bet you area and win is authenticated and will be paid without incurring any
    unwritten deductions.
    Depoxito as a site that is a accomplice of international big bookmakers extremely will not disappoint you as a loyal fanatic of the Depoxito
    site and will continue to strive for additional updates and revolutionize our
    security system correspondingly that it can prevent our loyal members
    from the threat of personal data leakage, scam
    or fraud.
    Depoxito is furthermore a trusted online gambling dealer that provides the most total gambling games in Indonesia, such
    as sportsbook, slot games, stir casino, lottery and online
    poker that you can be in with just 1 Account.
    In adjunct to the unconditional VIP help game on our site, we will pamper you our loyal members because you don’t craving a lot of IDs
    to do its stuff oscillate gambling games. As a gambling site accredited by PAGCOR (Philippines
    Amusement and Gaming Corporation) Depoxito is afterward one of the number one
    gambling sites in Indonesia and has a good reputation from all online gambling players in Indonesia.

    As we have said, we have a customer advance that is always on standby to assistance every your needs while playing on our site, including for withdrawals and deposits that and no-one
    else agree to less than 3 minutes, thus we can be the best for fanatic abet after that our customer support will standby
    24 hour a hours of daylight and 7 days a week to give support to our devotee and VIPs.

    And the most special from our site compared to further sites is the extra that we find the money for to
    our faithful members who continue to action upon our site
    will acquire the best promos and bonuses that we will meet the expense of you, we always follow the push and trends that are viral now correspondingly
    the promos that we create are of course no less than any
    site. For VIP members we always come up with the money for
    special promos that are not written as a result that our
    members continue to affect on our site depoxito

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.