Paste your Google Webmaster Tools verification code here

German revival exposes deep fissure within Europe’s economies

Posted by on February 20, 2014 in Economic Policy, Employment, Euro-zone, Financial Crisis, GDP, Inequality, Public Policy, Recession, Taxation | 22 comments

In the 1990s and early 2000s, Germany was seen by many as the new ‘Sick Man of Europe’. Between 1991 and 2005, GDP growth averaged only 1.2 per cent a year, compared to 3.3 per cent in the UK. Since then, the German economy has revived dramatically. The recovery in the German cluster of economies from the financial crisis has been as strong as in the United States, with the previous peak level of output being regained in 2011. Germany itself experienced virtually no increase in unemployment in 2008 and 2009, its exports are at record levels, and even the crisis in the Euro area has not prevented expansion in both output and employment.

There are two reasons which are frequently given for this. The first relates to the favourable exchange rate at which the German mark entered the Euro, giving an initial competitive edge to the economy. The second is the so-called ‘Hartz reforms’, a series of legislative labour market reforms which began in the mid-2000s. Both have validity.

There is a deeper reason for the recent turn-round in the performance of the German economy, which is rooted in institutional structures. In an article in the most recent Journal of Economic Perspectives – one of the world’s top academic journals – Christian Dustmann and colleagues agree with the general view that the evolution of unit labour costs has played a key role in the favourable performance of German tradable goods. But the main reason for this is in fact ‘the specific governance structure of German labor market institutions which allowed them to react flexibly in a time of extraordinary economic circumstances’.

German labour market flexibility is not based on legislation, but is laid out in contracts and mutual agreements between the three main actors in Germany: employer associations, trade unions, works councils. The formal institutional structure has remained unchanged, but there have been major changes in recent years in the way in which it works in practice. In particular, there has been a massive decentralisation of the wage-setting process from the industry level to the firm level, with a sharp fall in the proportion of workers covered by union agreements.

The fall of the Berlin Wall created opportunities for German industry to both source from, and relocate to, countries such as Poland and the Czech Republic which had stable political structures and skilled labour forces. Gradually, the German labour force appreciated that these developments required it to operate in a considerably more flexible way than it had previously. This has led to a rise in wage inequality within Germany, but the benefits have been a strong employment and output performance.

This decentralisation is in sharp contrast to economies such as Italy and France, where union wages and work hour agreements apply to all firms within an industry, or are subject to legal limits. These countries lack the flexibility and resilience which are required in a globalised economy. The structural problems of the EU run much deeper than the public debt issues revealed by the financial crisis.

As published in City AM on Wednesday 19th February 2013


  1. Secondary students will be trained in structured essay formats to optimize his or her writing expertise; as well, admission essays usually are used by
    colleges when deciding on candidates. You need to try to find information behind the statement, would it be supported
    with solid evidence. ” Then you can rewrite that same essay for the different college and say “I really enjoyed
    choosing Dr.

  2. The difficulties with confusing terminology, insufficient volume of
    science sources and again lack of knowledge is the reason why scientific topics the other from your worst topics for students to pay in their writing exams.

    Showing a passion for life and the issues you have accomplished needs to be the
    main focus associated with a admission essay.
    Avoid taking a risk this will let you set of professional eyes scrutinize your composition before submitting it for assessment.

  3. Essays, when it comes down to it, are among the simplest items to
    write as you are basically taking facts and turning them
    in to a short story, or perhaps in the situation of a comparative essay, a
    short “argument” or debate. the 1st CEO of IBM (International Business
    Machines) both brought tremendous boost in evolution of computer market and development.

    3) Manage your time and efforts wisely – This is probably the most critical indicators in determining that
    you will be in a position to finish the exam on time.

  4. Alternatively maybe you have decided that you
    just definitely want to experience University life to the full by living on campus, in a location that
    is the reasonable distance from your family home.

    For points where you will have much to express, you’ll be able to devote an entire
    sentence to each. No, better yet, go and get a favorite book, feel its heft inside your hand, run through its pages, smell its bookness.

  5. There is no use should you invest in a Part Time Course in Education and Training
    and end up with no work for yourself later. There have been a number of
    studies that try and put a monetary value on many of the methods UK universities help with society at
    both a nearby as well as a national level. Being just one father, one will spot himself deep into debt while spending money
    on principle life needs of his children.

  6. Put quotation marks across the titles of shorter works
    like journal or magazine articles: “Saturn’s Rings of Dust”If you might be quoting completely
    from a work, include the author, year of publication and the
    page number for your reference (precede the page number having a “p”.
    The second section supplies the evidence for a claim made inside first section. Spend just as much time
    as you have on each problem unless you grasp it, otherwise you could have wasted your
    time and efforts even considering it within the first

  7. It is always preferable to verify these courses
    along with their credentials before applying for the course.

    Prestigious universities and colleges have begun to recognize this,
    and they are constantly adding more course selection to their online class offerings.
    In fact, 32 percent of external hires originate from online job boards, when compared with 27
    percent from referrals.

  8. When planning the reaction to the question it is crucial the
    instruction word is considered and so the answer truly reflects the question. For the Judeo-Christian culture, Ecclesiastes 1:9 (written around 250 B.
    He means the ‘pedantic’ using a pejorative ring, AS IF
    being pedantic were something bad (a real tendency to become *against* pedantry is really a tendency quite
    characteristic of sophomoric fauxhemians and also other rinky dink, mediocre minds,
    so it’s all the more surprising when a profound
    thinker like Chesterton engages in such a dodgy manuever).

  9. They are not as crucial because the Deal Killer and Path Dependent Risks, but if not addressed
    might lead to a significant problem. I will reveal this more fully in a strategy for small establishments booklet potential
    published, fo the time being it may be best just to suggest some example
    businesses that might fit into each quadrant:Cost Leadership:
    Tesco. If you proceed with the open mind and truly study on other successful business leaders than your small business will grow.

  10. Therefore, ensure that you have lots of time
    to get these essays done. Culinary school also involves the skill sets
    future chefs should manage and run a successful restaurant.
    I believe consultants provide an extremely valuable service and that they must
    not cross the ethical line that would have students presenting an essay that isn’t theirs.

  11. Picture your good essay coming to the top from the pile and this is the reason why you should think of writing an essay to have scholarships for moms time for school.
    Browse through your textbooks for tips on what topics happen to be broached inside
    the past. Essay traveled to England inside the 16th century and got
    perfection using the endeavors of Francis bacon, the
    father of English essay.

  12. To study criminal justice is usually to ponder God’s purpose in establishing civil authorities.
    There are a number of courses that go to the formation of the
    good teacher. The placement season for 2013 has begun in an instant Students of Quantum Global Campus gets package of 10 laces per annum.

  13. Following MLA format in detail and learning the guidelines
    may help the student. Since it is the initial document that this
    editor will read upon submission, it really is important and you should definitely
    take the time to write a good letter. describe the cultural
    diversity discussed in the selected article and compare to cultural diversity in U.

  14. A lengthy story concerning one man trying to redeem himself from past
    sins, Les Miserables encompasses a lifetime of 16
    years in French society between 1815-1831: a tumultuous political era packed with inequality and political strife.
    A good consulting firm will not only aid your essay, and also help you with
    the application form process and getting ready for interviews.
    They are searching for that you are suffering from ideas and also communicate these ideas quickly and
    in your own voice.

  15. You can even flaunt your school pride by letting things that
    you can use to decorate your own home and your work space.
    Another attractive feature is that university
    teaching is normally over a nine month contract, leaving summers and holidays ready to accept special projects, workshops, or travel.
    Every bit as simple as installing Word – Press with Fantastico,
    however the theme gallery eliminates the call to later search for,
    and install, themes.

  16. Personally, I’d recommend with sticking them at first, as your primary points in advance helps ease the
    work for readers. This will greatly assist to make the
    writing assignment easier as well as ensuring
    the quality with the essay. Sometimes it is possible to answer the question inside
    of a creative way, but make sure you have a professional review of your answer
    (for interviews, practice this skill prior to actual interview.

  17. Create websites, squidoo pages or write articles and blogs about products or services that you simply personally have
    an interest in or used before, making a commision on any sales made through your page.
    More specifically, students train to get mathematicians, engineers, architects, doctors,
    scientists, researchers, economists, or physicists. This is especially true for college students that are residing in far areas and could
    afford to relocate nearby the college or university.

  18. Let’s look at some of the practices implemented by naturopathic doctors.

    Noida is a real home to several top-notch educational institutes which
    could groom you with advanced learning of MBA. In Obstetrics and
    Gynecologic Sonography become familiar with ways of handling and taking visual scans of the female reproductive :,
    along with the development and wellbeing of a growing fetus.

  19. Most in the times, the grants cover all of the expenses that
    are needed to pursue your education. Over the course
    in the Orientation Programme, the newest joinees in the batch of 2013-15 will be provided the opportunity connect to a
    number of other alumni who’ve developed a mark on their own within the corporate world.
    At present London shelters over 400,000 students which is the highest number if students in United

  20. Unless you are really sure you need to enter a “close” profession like medicine,
    architecture, accounting and law, then it’s vital
    that you study for any direct degree with an appropriate qualification, else in case you have no idea what you look
    for to complete, then, you might choose an arts
    degree because you much like the subject. And there can also be many ways of funding your education like scholarships, part payments,
    etc. Consider that colleges have to divvy up their athletic awards among all students; it is quite rare that an athletic scholarship covers
    all or even most of the cost of college.

  21. Canada is starting to become a preferred destination for international students.
    ” Research by Robert Boyce actually signifies that first and second-year professors who took part in a report on writing productivity were in a position to end up more publishable pages every year by . Those who prefer using images, symbols, colors to know some phenomena would rather making notes with writing some comments added margins and between lines of the text.

  22. It is a undeniable fact that those in holiday destinations will get customers from
    a billboard advertising qld ( that is certainly strategically placed for travellers to
    see. Businesses who utilize programmable LED signs get
    this amazing edge on people that have static signs. Depending about the
    model you select, these are generally commonly available in hand-painted, digitally printed, and
    digital billboards.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.